Just the other night while having dinner and drinks with friends, apart from catching up with each other, we indulged in a little discussion on money matters and the gender divide.Specifically, the theme was whether or not a man should pay for the woman every time. It sounds simple but in actual fact it isn’t because there are many facets or permutations to this question. I’m not an expert on social etiquettes and relationships but in the context of my own experience and opinion, here are some of the going concerns to be addressed…
A. Affiliation
1. Just Friends / Acquaintances
Straightforward. Go Dutch ie split the bill, go ‘a-a’. Unless it’s a business lunch and the meal expenses can be claimed or it’s a repayment in kind for a certain favour, there really isn’t any reason or obligation to settle the bill on behalf of anyone, unless you happen to be a philanthropist.
2. Close Friends / BFFs
Anything goes. There is no hard and fast rule on this one, because between buddies, a treat every now and then (or not) is to be expected. Besides, there’s no need to be shy for suggesting going Dutch.
3. Couples
This is the tricky part. At this stage of the relationship, this should be a non-issue but then many couples have often cited money as one of the main sources of disagreements in their relationships. In actual fact, anything goes because there shouldn’t really be any further formality or superficiality between couples. A detailed look is presented in Section B.
B. Couples - Timing
1. First Date
I think everyone on earth would agree with me that the men pay on the 1st date. No exemptions, no exceptions (maybe unless the guy’s dating a multi millionaire, but that would be a different discussion). If the girl refuses and insists on paying her share, then obviously it’s not a date to her (refer to A 1).
2. In A Relationship
Most couples have their own way of conducting their lives together. I know some who do not really have much care for formality and anything goes because, what belongs to him belongs to her and vice versa. On the other hand, I have seen some women who insist on being treated the same way as to when they were being courted. Their logic is simple – I fell for him because of how he feted me, so why should things change just because we’re a couple now? Likewise, I know guys who base their actions purely on ego – I’m the man so I should pay each and every time, because I’m the provider and she’s my dependent.
There is no right or wrong when it comes to couples because it’s all about character, behaviour, and attitude. At the end of the day, it all comes down to acceptance. If the girl can accept that her guy is stingy and a scrooge, then by all means. Else she should go find an affluent benefactor. And if the guy is willing to accept that his girl is high maintenance, so be it. Else he should look for a girl who is low maintenance.
C. Further considerations
As the conversation went on, different dimensions were put into the equation, for instance…
1. Differing attitudes between Chinese-educated and English-educated mindsets.
Some believe that girls from Chinese schools tend to want to be feted while those from English schools tend to be more independent. Likewise, guys from Chinese schools tend to be more traditionalist and egotistical ie insist on paying for everything every time while guys from English schools are more liberal and new age ie when it comes to money, egalitarian principles apply and all sexes are equal.
Of course this is just a general perception and not meant to be stereotypical.
2. Differing income level between genders
It is believed that in this day and age of equal opportunities and a (striving) egalitarian society, women not only have careers as good as their male counterparts but perhaps even better. The argument is this – if both men and women’s income at the same age group are on level terms, and as income levels increase in tandem with age, then younger women would tend to look for older men and vice versa if money were a concern for either party. This is because the guy whom a girl is dating and of the same age is less likely to be able to afford to pay for her needs, given that they earn the same amount.
Of course there is no statistics to support this and it’s just a general observation of the current demographics and state of economy.
3. Expected behavioural patterns…
A guy who pays for the girl may have either of these mentalities:
1. I paid for everything, so I should get something in return; or
2. I paid for everything because she’s worthy and deserving of my efforts; or
3. I paid for everything and it makes me look like a real man.
A guy who is paid for by the girl may have either of these mentalities:
1. It’s a 2-way relationship, and it shows she cares; or
2. She earns more than me, and it makes me look inadequate; or
3. I don’t mind at all and I hope I pay less from now on.
A girl who is paid for by the guy may have either of these mentalities:
1. He pays for me, so I’m obliged to / owned by him; or
2. He pays for me because he’s expected to anyway; or
3. He pays for me because he’s such a gentleman.
A girl who pays for the guy may have either of these mentalities:
1. I paid for him because I’m financially independent and I can afford to; or
2. I paid for him so I don’t owe him anything and therefore do not feel obligated; or
3. I paid for him because we’re a couple so we should share the financial burden.
Of course, the list of permutations and possibilities are actually endless and the examples above are non-exhaustive.
Conclusion
To be honest, there is no conclusion because everyone is different. There is no definite answer to should a guy pay for a woman each time. It’s dependent on the relationship that one is in, the couples’ mentality and attitude and also on the culture and what society expects.
Having said that, in my humble opinion, the men should ALWAYS OFFER to pay, whether he’s in a new relationship or have been married for years, or whether he can or cannot afford to, and it doesn’t really matter whether the lady earns her own keep or not because the gesture is more meaningful than the actual act. It’s akin to opening the door for a lady, irrespective of whether or not she’s capable of opening it herself because it’s courteous, respectful and chivalrous. And, to a certain extent, the guy would have to be terribly thick skinned and have it reflect badly on him to just let the door slam on her face. After all, if he’s doing it for someone whom he cherishes, then there really shouldn’t be any 2nd thought.
One thing’s for certain, though. There is only one way to find out which method works best – try either paying or not paying each time (if you’re a guy) or obliging to be paid for or offer to pay (if you’re a girl) and see what happens.
Disclaimer: The subject matter presented is purely the opinion of the author and not a representation of any expert or professional advice. Laksa Diaries will not be held liable for any break ups in relationships of readers who attempt to carry out the unsolicited and qualified suggestions of the author.







